• Documents
  • Authors
  • Tables
  • Log in
  • Sign up
  • MetaCart
  • DMCA
  • Donate

CiteSeerX logo

Advanced Search Include Citations
Advanced Search Include Citations

Naive learning in social networks: Convergence, influence, and the wisdom of crowds. Humanities, page Working Paper 64, (2007)

by B Golub, M O Jackson
Add To MetaCart

Tools

Sorted by:
Results 1 - 10 of 45
Next 10 →

Modeling Information Diffusion in Implicit Networks

by Jaewon Yang, Jure Leskovec
"... Abstract—Social media forms a central domain for the production and dissemination of real-time information. Even though such flows of information have traditionally been thought of as diffusion processes over social networks, the underlying phenomena are the result of a complex web of interactions a ..."
Abstract - Cited by 83 (2 self) - Add to MetaCart
Abstract—Social media forms a central domain for the production and dissemination of real-time information. Even though such flows of information have traditionally been thought of as diffusion processes over social networks, the underlying phenomena are the result of a complex web of interactions among numerous participants. Here we develop a Linear Influence Model where rather than requiring the knowledge of the social network and then modeling the diffusion by predicting which node will influence which other nodes in the network, we focus on modeling the global influence of a node on the rate of diffusion through the (implicit) network. We model the number of newly infected nodes as a function of which other nodes got infected in the past. For each node we estimate an influence function that quantifies how many subsequent infections can be attributed to the influence of that node over time. A nonparametric formulation of the model leads to a simple least squares problem that can be solved on large datasets. We validate our model on a set of 500 million tweets and a set of 170 million news articles and blog posts. We show that the Linear Influence Model accurately models influences of nodes and reliably predicts the temporal dynamics of information diffusion. We find that patterns of influence of individual participants differ significantly depending on the type of the node and the topic of the information. I.
(Show Context)

Citation Context

...in the dynamics of diffusion? Linear Influence Model (LIM). We consider the temporal variation in a diffusion-based framework and build on the view adopted by the literature on social influence [10], =-=[20]-=-. We formulate the Linear Influence Model (LIM) by starting with the assumption that the number of newly infected nodes depends on which other nodes got infected in the past. We then model the number ...

Networks in Finance

by Franklin Allen , Ana Babus - In The Network , 2009
"... Abstract Modern …nancial systems exhibit a high degree of interdependence. There are different possible sources of connections between …nancial institutions, stemming from both the asset and the liability side of their balance sheet. For instance, banks are directly connected through mutual exposur ..."
Abstract - Cited by 29 (0 self) - Add to MetaCart
Abstract Modern …nancial systems exhibit a high degree of interdependence. There are different possible sources of connections between …nancial institutions, stemming from both the asset and the liability side of their balance sheet. For instance, banks are directly connected through mutual exposures acquired on the interbank market. Likewise, holding similar portfolios or sharing the same mass of depositors creates indirect linkages between …nancial institutions. Broadly understood as a collection of nodes and links between nodes, networks can be a useful representation of …nancial systems. By providing means to model the speci…cs of economic interactions, network analysis can better explain certain economic phenomena. In this paper we argue that the use of network theories can enrich our understanding of …nancial systems. We review the recent developments in …nancial networks, highlighting the synergies created from applying network theory to answer …nancial questions. Further, we propose several directions of research. First, we consider the issue of systemic risk. In this context, two questions arise: how resilient …nancial networks are to contagion, and how …nan-cial institutions form connections when exposed to the risk of contagion. The second issue we consider is how network theory can be used to explain freezes in the interbank market of the type we have observed in August 2007 and subsequently. The third issue is how social networks can improve investment decisions and corporate governance. Recent empirical work has provided some interesting results in this regard. The fourth issue concerns the role of networks in distributing primary issues of securities as, for example, in initial public o¤erings, or seasoned debt and equity issues. Finally, we consider the role of networks as a form of mutual monitoring as in micro…nance.
(Show Context)

Citation Context

...ts face idiosyncratic and community-level shocks, networks that span communities can yield higher welfare than networks that connect all agents within a village. The use of network theory is especially relevant in analyzing product adoption decisions. The work by Katz and Shapiro (see Katz and Shapiro, 1994 and Economides, 1996 for surveys) captured situations where social pressure was critical, and individuals cared only about population averages. Recently there has been signi cant progress in studying di¤usion processes including explicit social network structures (Galeotti and Goyal, 2007; Golub and Jackson, 2007; Lopez-Pintado, 2007; Lopez-Pintado and Watts, 2007).2 However, the applications to industrial organization on research and development networks (Goyal and Moraga-Gonzales, 2001; Goyal et al., 2004) and trade agreements (Furusawa and Konishi, 2005) bring important insights. 3 Applications to Finance Modern nancial systems exhibit a high degree of interdependence. There are di¤erent possible sources of connections between nancial institutions, stemming from both the asset and the liability side of their balance sheet. Direct asset linkages result, for instance, from exposures between banks acq...

How bad is forming your own opinion

by David Bindel, Jon Kleinberg, Sigal Oren - In Proc. 52nd IEEE Symposium on Foundations of Computer Science , 2011
"... A long-standing line of work in economic theory has studied models by which a group of people in a social network, each holding a numerical opinion, can arrive at a shared opinion through repeated averaging with their neighbors in the network. Motivated by the observation that consensus is rarely re ..."
Abstract - Cited by 15 (1 self) - Add to MetaCart
A long-standing line of work in economic theory has studied models by which a group of people in a social network, each holding a numerical opinion, can arrive at a shared opinion through repeated averaging with their neighbors in the network. Motivated by the observation that consensus is rarely reached in real opinion dynamics, we study a related sociological model in which individuals ’ intrinsic beliefs counterbalance the averaging process and yield a diversity of opinions. By interpreting the repeated averaging as best-response dynamics in an underlying game with natural payoffs, and the limit of the process as an equilibrium, we are able to study the cost of disagreement in these models relative to a social optimum. We provide a tight bound on the cost at equilibrium relative to the optimum; our analysis draws a connection between these agreement models and extremal problems for generalized eigenvalues. We also consider a natural network design problem in this setting, where adding links to the underlying network can reduce the cost of disagreement at equilibrium.
(Show Context)

Citation Context

... An active line of recent work in economic theory has considered processes by which a group of people connected in a social network can arrive at a shared opinion through a form of repeated averaging =-=[1, 9, 12, 14]-=-. Much of this work builds on a basic model of DeGroot [8], in which we imagine that each person i holds an opinion equal to a real number zi, which might for example represent a position on a politic...

Control of preferences in social networks

by Georgios C. Chasparis, Jeff S. Shamma - in Decision and Control (CDC), 2010 49th IEEE Conference on , 2010
"... Abstract — We consider the problem of deriving optimal advertising policies for the spread of innovations in a social network. We seek to compute policies that account for i) endogenous network influences, ii) the presence of competitive firms, that also wish to influence the network, and iii) possi ..."
Abstract - Cited by 11 (0 self) - Add to MetaCart
Abstract — We consider the problem of deriving optimal advertising policies for the spread of innovations in a social network. We seek to compute policies that account for i) endogenous network influences, ii) the presence of competitive firms, that also wish to influence the network, and iii) possible uncertainties in the network model. Contrary to prior work in optimal advertising, which also accounts for network influences, we assume a dynamic model of preferences and we compute optimal policies for either finite or infinite horizons. We also compute robust optimal policies in the case where the evolution of preferences is also affected by external disturbances. Finally, in the presence of a competitive firm, we compute optimal Stackelberg and Nash solutions. I.

Community Structure and Market Outcomes: A Repeated Games in Networks Approach

by Itay P. Fainmesser , 2010
"... Consider a large market with asymmetric information, in which sellers choose whether to cooperate or deviate and ‘cheat’ their buyers, and buyers decide whether to re-purchase from different sellers. We model active trade relationships as links in a buyer-seller network and suggest a framework for s ..."
Abstract - Cited by 8 (2 self) - Add to MetaCart
Consider a large market with asymmetric information, in which sellers choose whether to cooperate or deviate and ‘cheat’ their buyers, and buyers decide whether to re-purchase from different sellers. We model active trade relationships as links in a buyer-seller network and suggest a framework for studying repeated games in such networks. In our framework, buyers and sellers have rich yet incomplete knowledge of the network structure; allowing us to derive meaningful conditions that determine whether a network is consistent with trade and cooperation between every buyer and seller that are connected. We show that three network features reduce the minimal discount factor necessary for sustaining cooperation: moderate competition, sparseness, and segregation. We find that the incentive constraints rule out networks that maximize the volume of trade and that the constrained trade maximizing networks are in between ‘old world’ segregated and sparse networks, and a ‘global market’.

Convergence of Rule-of-Thumb Learning Rules in Social Networks

by Daron Acemoglu, Angelia Nedić, Asuman Ozdaglar
"... Abstract — We study the problem of dynamic learning by a social network of agents. Each agent receives a signal about an underlying state and communicates with a subset of agents (his neighbors) in each period. The network is connected. In contrast to the majority of existing learning models, we foc ..."
Abstract - Cited by 8 (0 self) - Add to MetaCart
Abstract — We study the problem of dynamic learning by a social network of agents. Each agent receives a signal about an underlying state and communicates with a subset of agents (his neighbors) in each period. The network is connected. In contrast to the majority of existing learning models, we focus on the case where the underlying state is time-varying. We consider the following class of rule of thumb learning rules: at each period, each agent constructs his posterior as a weighted average of his prior, his signal and the information he receives from neighbors. The weights given to signals can vary over time and the weights given to neighbors can vary across agents. We distinguish between two subclasses: (1) constant weight rules; (2) diminishing weight rules. The latter reduces weights given to signals asymptotically to 0. Our main results characterize the asymptotic behavior of beliefs. We show that the general class of rules leads to unbiased estimates of the underlying state. When the underlying state has innovations with variance tending to zero asymptotically, we show that the diminishing weight rules ensure convergence in the mean-square sense. In contrast, when the underlying state has persistent innovations, constant weight rules enable us to characterize explicit bounds on the mean square error between an agent’s belief and the underlying state as a function of the type of learning rule and signal structure. I.
(Show Context)

Citation Context

...(while keeping the assumption of a single decision for each agent). 2 See, for example, Ellison and Fudenberg [8], [9], Bala and Goyal [2], [3], DeMarzo, Vayanos and Zwiebel [7] and Golub and Jackson =-=[11]-=-.error between individual beliefs and the underlying state. We distinguish two cases. In the first, the underlying state changes with diminishing innovations, that is, the variance of the innovations...

On approximations and ergodicity classes in random chains

by Behrouz Touri - IEEE Trans. on Automatic
"... ar ..."
Abstract - Cited by 8 (3 self) - Add to MetaCart
Abstract not found
(Show Context)

Citation Context

... problems arising in decentralized communication [5, 8, 29, 3], decentralized control [16, 27, 31, 20, 21], distributed optimization [38, 39, 30, 25, 17], and information diffusion in social networks =-=[14, 1]-=-. In many of these applications, the ergodicity plays a central role in ensuring that the local “agent” information diffuses eventually over the entire network of agents. The conditions under which th...

How Homophily Affects Diffusion and Learning in Networks

by Benjamin Golub, Matthew O. Jackson , 2010
"... We examine how diffusion and learning processes are influenced by network properties, focusing on density and homophily – the tendency of agents to associate disproportionately with those sharing similar traits. Homophily does not affect the speed of diffusions that travel along shortest paths; thei ..."
Abstract - Cited by 6 (1 self) - Add to MetaCart
We examine how diffusion and learning processes are influenced by network properties, focusing on density and homophily – the tendency of agents to associate disproportionately with those sharing similar traits. Homophily does not affect the speed of diffusions that travel along shortest paths; their rate is determined only by the size of the society and the number of links per agent. In contrast, homophily substantially slows learning based on repeated averaging of neighbors’ information. Our analysis shows that changing a network can have widely different effects on information flow depending on the details of the transmission process and we provide general tools for analyzing such changes.

Heterogeneous beliefs and local information in stochastic fictitious play

by Drew Fudenberg, Satoru Takahashi - Games and Economic Behavior , 2008
"... Stochastic …ctitious play (SFP) assumes that agents do not try to in‡uence the future play of their current opponents, an assumption that is justi…ed by appeal to a setting with a large population of players who are randomly matched to play the game. However, the dynamics of SFP have only been analy ..."
Abstract - Cited by 5 (1 self) - Add to MetaCart
Stochastic …ctitious play (SFP) assumes that agents do not try to in‡uence the future play of their current opponents, an assumption that is justi…ed by appeal to a setting with a large population of players who are randomly matched to play the game. However, the dynamics of SFP have only been analyzed in models where all agents in a player role have the same beliefs. We analyze the dynamics of SFP in settings where there is a population of agents who observe only outcomes in their own matches and thus have heterogeneous beliefs. We provide conditions that ensure that the system converges to a state with homogeneous beliefs, and that its asymptotic behavior is the same as with a single representative agent in each player role. We thank Michel Benaïm. Josef Hofbauer, and William Sandholm for very helpful comments and suggestions. 1 1

Threshold learning dynamics in social networks

by Juan Carlos González-avella, Victor M. Eguı́luz, Matteo Marsili, Fernado Vega-redondo, Maxi San - PLoS ONE , 2011
"... Social learning is defined as the ability of a population to aggregate information, a process which must crucially depend on the mechanisms of social interaction. Consumers choosing which product to buy, or voters deciding which option to take with respect to an important issue, typically confront e ..."
Abstract - Cited by 5 (2 self) - Add to MetaCart
Social learning is defined as the ability of a population to aggregate information, a process which must crucially depend on the mechanisms of social interaction. Consumers choosing which product to buy, or voters deciding which option to take with respect to an important issue, typically confront external signals to the information gathered from their contacts. Economic models typically predict that correct social learning occurs in large populations unless some individuals display unbounded influence. We challenge this conclusion by showing that an intuitive threshold process of individual adjustment does not always lead to such social learning. We find, specifically, that three generic regimes exist separated by sharp discontinuous transitions. And only in one of them, where the threshold is within a suitable intermediate range, the population learns the correct information. In the other two, where the threshold is either too high or too low, the system either freezes or enters into persistent flux, respectively. These regimes are generally observed in different social networks (both complex or regular), but limited interaction is found to promote correct learning by enlarging the parameter region where it occurs.
(Show Context)

Citation Context

...vely of the network architecture. On the other hand, to attain correct learning, one must require not only that the population be large but, in the limit, that no individual retain too much influence =-=[14,15]-=-. PLoS ONE | www.plosone.org 1 May 2011 | Volume 6 | Issue 5 | e20207 The model studied in this paper displays some similarities to, as well as crucial differences with, those outlined above. To fix i...

Powered by: Apache Solr
  • About CiteSeerX
  • Submit and Index Documents
  • Privacy Policy
  • Help
  • Data
  • Source
  • Contact Us

Developed at and hosted by The College of Information Sciences and Technology

© 2007-2019 The Pennsylvania State University