See this document in CiteSeerX!

Representation of Formal Dispute with a Standing Order (1996)  (Make Corrections)  (7 citations)
Gerard A.W. Vreeswijk
Artificial Intelligence and Law



  Home/Search   Context   Related

 
View or download:
cs.unimaas.nl/pub/papers/vre...pps.ps.Z
cs.unimaas.nl/pub/papers/g...cs9509.ps
Cached:  PS.gz  PS  PDF   Image  Update  Help

From:  fermivista.math...p.cs.unimaas.nl (more)
From:  fermivista.math...p.cs.unimaas.nl
(Enter author homepages)

Rate this article: (best)
  Comment on this article  
(Enter summary)

Abstract: Computational dialectics is a relatively new field. It is, among others, concerned with the formal representation of argument and dispute. The goal is to suggest algorithms, procedures and protocols to investigate the tenability of logical claims, on the basis of incomplete and uncertain information. (Usually in the form of rules and cases.) Currently, the field slowly converges to the opinion that dispute is the most fair and effective way to investigate claims. The definition of a formal... (Update)

Context of citations to this paper:   More

...con and expresses the resolution of their conflict as a priority rule. However, his method is not embedded in a dialectical context. Vreeswijk (1996) has earlier embedded HYPO style reasoning in a formally defined dialectical protocol, but since this is not the main theme of his...

.... re emphasized in the artificial intelligence community (see, e.g. Gordon [9] Hage et al. 10] Lodder [11] Loui [12] Vreeswijk [13]) Argumentation diagrams are useful for the understanding of the process of argumentation. For instance, specific argumentation strategies...

Cited by:   More
Dynamic Argument Systems: A Formal Model of Argumentation.. - Brewka (2000)   (Correct)
The Role of Logic in Computational Models of Legal Argument - .. - Prakken, Sartor (2001)   (Correct)
Two Approaches to Dialectical Argumentation: Admissible Sets and.. - Verheij (1996)   (Correct)

Active bibliography (related documents):   More   All
1.9:   Research Notes on Computational Issues in Defeasible Reasoning - Vreeswijk   (Correct)
0.5:   Process And Policy: Resource-Bounded Non-Demonstrative Reasoning - Loui (1993)   (Correct)
0.4:   Searching for the Impossible in Multi-agent Systems - Vreeswijk   (Correct)

Similar documents based on text:   More   All
0.3:   IACAS: an Implementation of Chisholm's Principles of Knowledge.. - Vreeswijk   (Correct)
0.3:   Relating Protocols for Dynamic Dispute with Logics for Defeasible .. - Prakken (2000)   (Correct)
0.3:   Open Protocol in Multi-agent Systems - Vreeswijk (1995)   (Correct)

Related documents from co-citation:   More   All
5:   the acceptability of arguments and its fundamental role in nonmonotonic reasonin.. - Dung - 1995
4:   Logical tools for modelling legal argument (context) - Prakken - 1993
4:   Process and policy: resource--bounded non--demonstrative reasoning - Loui - 1993

BibTeX entry:   (Update)

G.A.W. Vreeswijk, Representation of formal dispute with a standing order. Research Report MATRIX, University of Limburg. http://citeseer.ist.psu.edu/vreeswijk96representation.html   More

@article{ vreeswijk00representation,
    author = "Gerard Vreeswijk",
    title = "Representation of formal dispute with a standing order",
    journal = "Artificial Intelligence and Law",
    volume = "8",
    number = "2/3",
    pages = "205-231",
    year = "2000",
    url = "citeseer.ist.psu.edu/vreeswijk96representation.html" }
Citations (may not include all citations):
159   the acceptability of arguments and its fundamental role in n.. - Dung - 1995
65   the Comparison of Theories: Preferring the Most Specific Exp.. (context) - Poole - 1985
39   Defeat Among Arguments: A System of Defeasible Inference (context) - Loui - 1987
31   Studies in Defeasible Argumentation (context) - Vreeswijk - 1993
17   Defeasible Reasoning and Decision Support Systems (context) - Nute - 1988
17   Justification and defeat - Pollock - 1994
15   A Reconstruction of Rescher's Theory of Formal Disputation B.. (context) - Brewka - 1994
15   Defeasible Dialectics: A Controversy-Oriented Approach towar.. - Vreeswijk - 1993
9   Theory of Knowledge (context) - Chisholm - 1977
9   Principles for Democratic Control of Bounded-Rational (context) - Page - 1991
7   The Computational Value of Debate in Defeasible Reasoning - Vreeswijk
7   IACAS: an implementation of Chisholm's principles of knowled.. - Vreeswijk
6   Formalizing Nomic: working on a theory of communication with.. - Vreeswijk - 1995
6   Ampliative Inference (context) - Loui - 1990
5   Logical Tools for Modeling Legal Argument (context) - Prakken - 1993
4   Accrual of arguments in defeasible argumentation - Verheij
3   Arguments and Defeat in Argument-based Nonmonotonic Reasonin.. - Verheij
3   IACAS user manual v1 (context) - Vreeswijk - 1994
3   Argument and Arbitration Games (context) - Loui - 1994
2   Formal Systems of Dialogue Rules (context) - Krabbe - 1985
1   Emergent Political Structures in Abstract Forms of Rulemakin.. (context) - Vreeswijk
1   Defeat Among Arguments II (context) - Loui - 1989



The graph only includes citing articles where the year of publication is known.


Documents on the same site (http://fermivista.math.jussieu.fr/ftp/ftp.cs.unimaas.nl.html):   More
Defeasible Dialectics: A Controversy-Oriented Approach towards.. - Vreeswijk (1993)   (Correct)
Self-modifying Protocol Games: A Preparatory Case Study - Vreeswijk   (Correct)
Research Notes on Computational Issues in Defeasible Reasoning - Vreeswijk   (Correct)

Online articles have much greater impact   More about CiteSeer.IST   Add search form to your site   Submit documents   Feedback  

CiteSeer.IST - Copyright Penn State and NEC