Abstract:
Abstract. We tend to talk about (refer to, quantify over) parts in the same way in which we talk about whole objects. Yet a part is not something to be included in an inventory of the world over and above the whole to which it belongs, and a whole is not something to be included in an inventory over and above its own parts. This paper is an attempt to clarify a way of dealing with this tension which may be labeled the Minimalist View: an element in the field of a part-whole relation is to be included in an inventory of the world if, and only if, it does not overlap any other element that is itself included in the inventory. As it turns out, a clarification of this view involves both a defense of mereological extensionality and an account of the topological distinction between detached and undetached parts (and the parallel opposition between scattered and connected wholes). 1.
Citations
|
202
|
A.: Naming and Necessity
– Kripke
|
|
197
|
Parts: a study in ontology
– Simons
- 1987
|
|
60
|
Parts, wholes, and part-whole relations: The prospects of mereotopology
– Varzi
- 1996
|
|
50
|
Frege: Philosophy of Language
– Dummett
- 1973
|
|
30
|
The Concept of Identity
– Hirsch
- 1982
|
|
29
|
Die Grundlagen der Arithmetik. Eine logisch-mathematische Untersuchung über den Begriff der Zahl. Breslau: Koebner
– Frege
|
|
16
|
Characteristica universalis
– Smith
- 1992
|
|
13
|
Scattered Objects
– Cartwright
- 1975
|
|
10
|
Events as Property Exemplifications
– Kim
- 1976
|
|
10
|
Things That Happen
– Tiles
- 1981
|
|
9
|
Contingent identity
– Gibbard
- 1975
|
|
9
|
Modality and Description
– Smullyan
- 1948
|
|
8
|
Occasions of Identity
– Gallois
- 1998
|
|
8
|
The Many Faces of Realism
– Putnam
- 1987
|
|
8
|
Designation and existence
– Quine
- 1949
|
|
7
|
The Time of a Killing
– Thomson
- 1971
|
|
6
|
Podstawy ogólnej teoryi mnogo´sci. I, Moskow: Prace Polskiego Ko′la Naukowego w Moskwie
– Les´niewski
- 1916
|
|
6
|
There are no ordinary things
– Unger
- 1979
|
|
6
|
On Being in the Same Place at the Same Time
– Wiggins
- 1968
|
|
5
|
Under a Description’, Noûs 13
– Anscombe
- 1979
|
|
5
|
Events and Event Talk: An Introduction
– Pianesi, Varzi
- 2000
|
|
5
|
The problem of material constitution
– Rea
- 1995
|
|
4
|
Dion and Theon: An Essentialist Solution to an Ancient Puzzle
– Burke
- 1994
|
|
4
|
The Stoic Criterion
– Sedley
- 1982
|
|
3
|
What is a criterion of identity? The Philosophical Quarterly
– Lowe
- 1989
|
|
3
|
The Doctrine of Arbitrary Undetached
– Inwagen
- 1981
|
|
3
|
Identity, Essence, and Indiscernibility
– Yablo
- 1987
|
|
2
|
Identity Conditions for Events’, American Philosophical Quarterly 14, 329–337
– Brand
- 1977
|
|
2
|
Essentialists and Essentialism
– M
- 1996
|
|
2
|
Theon’s Tale: Does a Cambridge Change Result in a Substantial Change?’, Analysis 55
– Denkel
- 1995
|
|
1
|
The Theory of Categories, The Hague
– Chisholm, Guterman
- 1981
|
|
1
|
30 The analogy is from Simons [1991: 91]. 31 Parts of this paper have been delivered at MIT, at the CUNY Graduate Center, and at the universities of
– Many
|
|
1
|
Parts and Places. The Structures of Spatial Representation
– 1999b
|
|
1
|
The Loose and Popular and the Strict and Philosophical Senses of Identity
– Chisholm
- 1969
|
|
1
|
of the General Theory of Sets
– Barnett
- 1992
|
|
1
|
Parts of Classes, Oxford and
– Lewis
- 1991
|
|
1
|
Identity Through Time: One Last Run for the Ordinary View’, Pacific Philosophical Quarterly 64
– Michaels
- 1983
|
|
1
|
Identity and Time
– Myro
- 1985
|
|
1
|
Four-Dimensionalism’, The Philosophical Review 106
– Sider
- 1997
|
|
1
|
Reasoning about Space: The Hole Story
– 1996b
|
|
1
|
Treatise on Syncategorematic Words, trans. by N
– Sherwood
- 1968
|
