Henry Prakken, Giovanni Sartor  Home/Search
Context Related
| cs.uu.nl/people/henry/...Precdia98.ps.Z cs.vu.nl/~henry/ps/Precdia98.ps.Z cs.uu.nl/groups/IS/archi...Precdia98.ps Cached: PS.gz PS PDF This document uses CoBlitz to cache paper downloads. If your firewall is blocking outgoing connections to port 3125, you can use these links to download local copies.
Image Update HelpPS.gz PS PDF From: cs.uu.nl/people/he...publications (more) From: cs.vu.nl/~henry/publications (Enter author homepages) |
Rate this article:      (best)Comment on this article |
Abstract: . This paper analyses legal reasoning with precedents in the setting of a formally defined dialogue game. After giving a legal-theoretical account of judicial reasoning with precedents, a formal method is proposed for representing precedents and it is discussed how such representations can be used in a formally defined dialectical protocol for dispute. The basic ideas are to represent cases as argument structures (including pro and con arguments, and the arguments for adjudicating their... (Update)
Context of citations to this paper: More
.... assume that utilities of different outcomes are comparable and may Dialogue games have also been applied to problems in legal reasoning [8, 59], in software specification [20] and in automated software design [68] These are instances of a Game Theoretic semantics in the sense...
...are entitled to infer. This latter effect is given by using the method of Prakken and Sartor for producing rules from cases given in [4], whereby the conjunction of pro plaintiff factors gives one rule, the conjunction of pro defendant factors another, and the priority is...
Cited by: More
Coherence Constraints for Agent Interaction - Joris Hulstijn Frank (2004) (Correct)
A Persuasion Dialogue Game Based on Commitments and.. - Bentahar, Moulin.. (Correct)
Dialogue Games in Multi-Agent Systems - McBurney, Parsons (Correct)
Similar documents (at the sentence level):
8.9%: Reasoning with Precedents in a Dialogue Game - Prakken, Sartor (1997) (Correct)
Active bibliography (related documents): More All
1.1: The Role of Logic in Computational Models of Legal Argument - .. - Prakken, Sartor (2001) (Correct)
0.8: Dialectic Semantics for Argumentation Frameworks - Jakobovits, Vermeir (1999) (Correct)
0.7: A Computational Model of Ratio Decidendi - Branting (1994) (Correct)
Similar documents based on text: More All
0.8: An Exercise in Formalising Teleological Case-Based Reasoning - Prakken (2001) (Correct)
0.7: A Dialectical Model of Assessing Conflicting Arguments in.. - Prakken, Sartor (1996) (Correct)
0.5: An exercise in formalising teleological case-based reasoning.. - Prakken (2000) (Correct)
Related documents from co-citation: More All
5: Agents that reason and negotiate by arguing - Parsons, Sierra et al. - 1998
5: Commitment in Dialogue: Basic Concepts of Interpersonal Reasoning (context) - Krabbe, Krabbe - 1995
5: Argument--based extended logic programming with defeasible priorities - Sartor
BibTeX entry: (Update)
H. Prakken & G. Sartor, Modelling reasoning with precedents in a formal dialogue game. Submitted. http://citeseer.ist.psu.edu/prakken98modelling.html More
@article{ prakken98modelling,
author = "Henry Prakken and Giovanni Sartor",
title = "Modelling Reasoning with Precedents in a Formal Dialogue Game",
journal = "Artificial Intelligence and Law",
volume = "6",
number = "2-4",
pages = "231-287",
year = "1998",
url = "citeseer.ist.psu.edu/prakken98modelling.html" }
Citations (may not include all citations):159 the acceptability of arguments and its fundamental role in n.. - Dung - 1995
93 Defeasible reasoning (context) - Pollock - 1987
78 Logical Tools for Modelling Legal Argument (context) - Prakken - 1993
78 Logical Tools for Modelling Legal Argument (context) - Prakken - 1997
76 New York (context) - the, Conference et al. - 1992
57 Conditional entailment: bridging two approaches to default r.. (context) - Geffner, Pearl - 1992
46 Modeling Legal Argument: Reasoning with Cases and Hypothetic.. (context) - Ashley - 1990
42 Argument-based extended logic programming with defeasible pr.. - Prakken, Sartor
41 argumentation-theoretic approach to default reasoning - Bondarenko, Dung et al. - 1997
41 Abstract argumentation systems (context) - Vreeswijk - 1997
39 Defeat among arguments: a system of defeasible inference (context) - Loui - 1987
37 The Zeno argumentation framework - Gordon, Karacapilidis - 1997
35 Dialectics: a Controversy-oriented Approach to the Theory of.. (context) - Rescher - 1977
30 Process and policy: resource-bounded non-demonstrative reaso.. - Loui - 1998
28 CABARET: rule interpretation in a hybrid architecture (context) - Skalak, Rissland - 1991
19 A dialectical model of assessing conflicting arguments in le.. - Prakken, Sartor
14 From logic to dialectics in legal argument - Prakken - 1995
13 Rules and precedents as complementary warrants - Branting, Porter - 1991
13 Hard cases: a procedural approach (context) - Hage, Leenes et al. - 1994
10 The Pleadings Game (context) - Gordon - 1995
10 Reasoning With Rules (context) - Hage - 1997
8 How different is different (context) - Aleven, Ashley - 1996
8 Reasoning with portions of precedents - Branting - 1991
8 The representation of an evolving system of legal concepts: .. (context) - McCarty, Sridharan - 1981
7 Practical Reason and Norms (context) - Raz - 1975
7 A theory of legal reasoning and a logic to match (context) - Hage - 1996
7 Representation of formal dispute with a standing order - Vreeswijk - 1996
7 An implementation of Eisner v (context) - McCarty - 1995
6 A Theory of Legal Argumentation (context) - Alexy - 1989
6 Taking Rights Seriously (context) - Dworkin - 1977
6 A computational model of ratio decidendi - Branting - 1994
6 Formal Studies of Argumentation and Defeat (context) - Verheij - 1996
6 Rationales and argument moves (context) - Loui, Norman - 1995
5 Dialectical proof theory for defeasible argumentation with d.. - Prakken - 1998
4 How to buy a Porsche (context) - Brewka, Gordon - 1994
4 Precedent in English Law (context) - Cross, Harris - 1991
3 The Authority of the Law (context) - Raz - 1989
3 Arguments and cases (context) - Skalak, Rissland - 1992
3 How to do Things with Rules (context) - Twining, Miers - 1991
2 Some arguments about legal arguments (context) - McCarty - 1997
2 A Matter of Principle (context) - Dworkin - 1985
2 Reasoning with precedents in a dialogue game - Prakken, Sartor
1 Eliding the arguments of cases (context) - Loui, Norman - 1997
1 A case-based system for trade secrets law (context) - with, in et al. - 1987
1 To appear in Computational Intelligence (context) - in, Loui et al. - 1993
1 reprint of Artificial Intelligence and Law (context) - Prakken, Sartor - 1996
1 Precedent in Law (context) - Goldstein - 1987
1 Harmondsworth: Penguin (context) - Mill - 1974
1 Justification of Legal Decisions (context) - Wroblewski - 1969
1 Learning the Law (context) - Williams - 1982
1 Understanding precedents in a temporal contex of evolving le.. (context) - Berman, Hafner - 1995
1 A system for defeasible argumentation (context) - Springer, Prakken et al.
1 Legal Reasoning and Legal Theory (context) - MacCormick - 1978
1 Precedent in the United States (context) - Intelligence, -- - 1997
1 Logic and argumentation in legal reasoning (context) - Sartor - 1997
1 Evaluating a learning environment for case-based argumentati.. (context) - Smith, Faltings et al. - 1997
1 La Motivazione della Sentenza Civile (context) - Taruffo - 1975
1 Why cases have rationes and what these are (context) - MacCormick - 1987
The graph only includes citing articles where the year of publication is known.
Documents on the same site (http://www.cs.uu.nl/people/henry/publications.html): More
Dyadic Deontic Logic And Contrary-To-Duty Obligations - Prakken, Sergot (1997) (Correct)
From Logic to Dialectics in Legal Argument - Prakken (1995) (Correct)
On the Relation Between Legal Language and Legal Argument.. - Prakken, Sartor (1995) (Correct)
Online articles have much greater impact More about CiteSeer.IST Add search form to your site Submit documents Feedback
CiteSeer.IST - Copyright Penn State and NEC