Reboh, R. Extracting Useful Advice From Conflicting Expertise. Proceedings of the International Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence 1(1983) Pps. 145-150.  Home/Search   Document Not in Database   Summary   Related Articles   Check

.... is represented and reasoned with explicitly using formalisms as robust as those used for other kinds of expertise: Development Time Conflict Resolution: Systems of this type require that potential conflicts be compiled out of them by virtue of exhaustive discussions when they are developed [3, 34, 48, 51, 39]. The conflict resolution knowledge utilized by the domain Mark Klein Conflict Management 4 experts is then implicit in the individual conflict resolution decisions made during development. This approach has a number of serious disadvantages. For example, it is very time consuming to change or ....

Reboh, R. Extracting Useful Advice From Conflicting Expertise. Proceedings of the International Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence 1(1983) Pps. 145-150.

....to (e.g. resolving) incommensurate conceptualizations. For example, the learning agent may search input for specific types of incompatibilities (e.g. task specification errors [FN88] or the learning agent may permit different conceptualizations and resolve them internally (e.g. with contexts [Reb83, Cla90, Guh91] or the learning agent may not address or even notice incommensurate conceptualizations until they result in conflicts in the growing knowledge base (e.g. KI, the program described in Chapters 3 5. However, KI does interactively present the consequences of new information so ....

R. Reboh. Extracting useful advice from conflicting expertise. In Proceedings of the International Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence, pages 145--150, 1983.

.... is represented and reasoned with explicitly using formalisms as robust as those used for other kinds of expertise: Development Time Conflict Resolution: Systems of this type require that potential conflicts be compiled out of them by virtue of exhaustive discussions when they are developed [2, 36, 47, 50, 39]. The conflict resolution knowledge utilized by the domain experts is then implicit in the individual conflict resolution decisions made during development. This approach has a number of serious disadvantages. For example, it is very time consuming to change or add to the existing design agents. ....

Reboh, R. Extracting Useful Advice From Conflicting Expertise. Proceedings of the International Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence 1(1983) Pps. 145-150.

....[Alexander and Evans, 1988] It is also clear that the value of such discussions in solving problems is dependent on the availability of experts, and their knowledge of and ability to recall relevant previous cases. Assistance in this process would thus be valuable, and as Reboh points out [Reboh, 1983] expert system research offers precisely a technology in which this expert reasoning can be captured and, by combining this with the computer s power for faithful memory and extensive search, provide a useful decision support tool. In this paper, we highlight the problems in constructing such a ....

.... optimistically raised the hope that discussion about Prospectors models would smooth out the disagreements [Gaschnig, 1982] Finally, in 1983 Reboh argues in favour of modelling (rather than seeking to eradicate) conflicting expertise and speculates on some of the mechanisms for doing this [Reboh, 1983]. The techniques which we present are thus also relevant to other domains such as these. 2.3 Applying Expert System Technology The above problem characteristics make it particularly difficult to apply the normal expert system methodology of identifying and encoding the right expertise for ....

Reboh, R. (1983). Extracting useful advice from conflicting expertise. In IJCAI-83, volume 1, pages 145--150.

Online articles have much greater impact   More about CiteSeer.IST   Add search form to your site   Submit documents   Feedback  

CiteSeer.IST - Copyright Penn State and NEC