E. Domeshek and J. Kolodner. Towards a Case-Based Aid for Conceptual Design. In Int. Journal of Expert Systems Research and Applications. Vol. 4 No. 2, pp. 201-220. 1991.  Home/Search   Document Not in Database   Summary   Related Articles   Check

....in addition to a library of past designs, provides access to design guidelines and principles in the domain of interface design. ArchieTutor [Goel et al. 1993] is a new version of Archie that takes into account the lessons learned form AskJef about providing access to domain knowledge. Archie2 [Domeshek and Kolodner 1991] is a newer version of Archie whose emphasis is on ensuring that the important lessons from each past design are communicated to the users. Canah chab can also be seen as a case based design system. It provides access to an external memory of past design cases. However, important lessons learned ....

E. Domeshek and J. Kolodner. Towards a Case-Based Aid for Conceptual Design. In Int. Journal of Expert Systems Research and Applications. Vol. 4 No. 2, pp. 201-220. 1991.

....involved in the conflict has to be manoeuvred and the type of manoeuvre that has to be applied. It seemed that because of this double solution each case could be broken into two sub structures, each one dealing with one part of the solution as done in APU (Bhansali and Harandi, 1993) and ARCHIE (Domeshek and Kolodner, 1992). The alternative of having one solution that includes both the components at the same time is simpler and proved to work as well. Very often in the ATC domain a conflict involves more than two aircraft. If this happens we have a multiple aircraft conflict that can be decomposed into two aircraft ....

....1989) 3.2.2 The Case Representation This proved to be the key issue in ISAC. A concrete case representation is available from the host system that is the basis of the actual case representation, so the initial set of parameters will be acquired from the host system as is done in Archie (Domeshek and Kolodner, 1992). Many of the parameters are represented numerically but sometimes the representation is expanded to produce some more abstract symbolic parameters that support useful reminding in the case retrieval process. A similar approach for the conversion of numeric parameters into symbolic ones with the ....

Domeshek E., Kolodner J. (1992). Toward a Case-based Aid for Conceptual Design, International Journal of Expert Systems, Vol.4, No.2.

....from cases. On the international level, the work done by the group around Janet Kolodner is probably most advanced. Quite recently, they assessed their rather negative experiences with their architecture system Archie and formulated them as requirements for the successor system Archie II [ Domeshek and Kolodner, 1992 ] Essentially, they aim at supporting rather than automating human activities, at small cases covering partial designs rather than fully worked out plans, at a graphical interface based on the drawings architects are accustomed to, and at a flexibel hypermedia navigation aid. These are ....

E. Domeshek and J. Kolodner. Toward a case-based aid for conceptual design. Int. Journal of Expert Systems, to appear, 1992.

....and time consuming task that has proven a serious impediment to developing autonomous case based reasoning systems. As a result, many CBR systems now function as retrieval only decision support systems, relying on their human users to adapt their cases (Blevis, Burke, Glasgow, Duncan, 1991; Domeshek Kolodner, 1992; Hennessey Hinkle, 1991; Kitano, Shibata, Shimazu, Kajihara, Sato, 1992; Simoudis Miller, 1991; Slator Riesbeck, 1991) For example, one such system is an aiding and advisory system for architects (Domeshek Kolodner, 1992) it presents relevant cases to architects who themselves decide ....

.... users to adapt their cases (Blevis, Burke, Glasgow, Duncan, 1991; Domeshek Kolodner, 1992; Hennessey Hinkle, 1991; Kitano, Shibata, Shimazu, Kajihara, Sato, 1992; Simoudis Miller, 1991; Slator Riesbeck, 1991) For example, one such system is an aiding and advisory system for architects (Domeshek Kolodner, 1992); it presents relevant cases to architects who themselves decide how to apply the cases to new architectural design problems. Such decision support systems have proven a very useful application of CBR, but developing fully automated CBR systems that can be used by expert and naive users alike ....

Domeshek, E. & Kolodner, J. (1992). Towards a case-based aid for conceptual design. International Journal of Expert Systems, 4(2), 201--220.

.... that developers of CBR applications should focus on building decision aiding systems that function primarily as memories, with a human user performing case adaptation (e.g. Kolodner, 1991 ] and by the many current systems that do not perform case adaptation (e.g. Blevis et al. 1991; Domeshek and Kolodner, 1991; Hennessey and Hinkle, 1991; Simoudis and Miller, 1991; Slator and Riesbeck, 1991 ] Although focusing on the retrieval aspects of CBR is probably now the best way to build CBR applications, it has the practical drawback of requiring user expertise to apply retrieved cases the user must be a ....

Domeshek, E. and Kolodner, J. 1991. Toward a case-based aid for conceptual design. International Journal of Expert Systems 4(2):201--220.

.... 1991; Leake, 1994b) The difficulty in hand coding case adaptation knowledge is so acute that many CBR applications do not even include case adaptation, leaving adaptation to be performed manually by the users of the systems (e.g. Bayles Das (1994) Blevis, Burke, Glasgow, Duncan (1991) Domeshek Kolodner (1992), Hennessey Hinkle (1991) Simoudis Miller (1991) Slator Riesbeck (1991) This makes the systems into expert memories without the capability to apply the contents of those memories themselves. We are addressing the problem of defining adaptation criteria by modeling how a case based ....

Domeshek, E. & Kolodner, J. (1992). Towards a case-based aid for conceptual design.

....the centrality of case data and the focus on conceptual design issues. However, the system produced was inadequate as an aid for designers on a number of practical grounds, most notably its monolithic representation of design cases. and its inability to communicate design lessons to users (Domeshek and Kolodner, 1991). One response was presented in our AI in Design 92 paper (Domeshek and Kolodner, 1992) which described our plan for a story centered hypermedia browsing system organized around artifacts and design issues. 2 At that time, we had only a SuperCard mock up, serving primarily as a tool for ....

Domeshek, E.A. and Kolodner, J.L.: 1991, Towards a Case-Based Aid for Conceptual Design. Int. Journal of Expert Systems Research and Applications, 4(2), 201-220.

Online articles have much greater impact   More about CiteSeer.IST   Add search form to your site   Submit documents   Feedback  

CiteSeer.IST - Copyright Penn State and NEC