Kolb, D. Scholarly Hypertext: Self-Represented Complexity. In Proceedings of The Eighth ACM Conference on Hypertext, Southampton, 1997, pp. 2937  Home/Search   Document Details and Download   Summary   Related Articles   Check

....rule Argument structure Subclaim Figure 2: A generic graphical argument using a claimsarguments evidence structuring motif This formulation is for arguments supporting claims about systems. Other domains for rigorous argumentation would assert claims about that domain. In the limit, Kolb [7] conceives of tools that could even enable argumentation about its own structures ( scholarly hypertext ) 1.2 Integrating narrative and graphical notation into a hypertext argumentation approach There are deficiencies in just using plain narrative, or a purely graphical notation. Pure ....

Kolb, D. Scholarly Hypertext: Self-Represented Complexity. In Proceedings of The Eighth ACM Conference on Hypertext, Southampton, 1997, pp. 2937

....and systems is still to provide audio visual information primarily for descriptive purposes while the main information is conveyed through text. While this methodology provides a means for modelling argumentative discourse in general [16] sophisticated requirements for scholarly argumentation [31, 28], or establishing large narratives [62] we claim that within hypermedia systems this linguistic centred view needs extension through a semiotic based approach if different media are to achieve real analytic parity with text. Semiotics is here understood as the study of signs, in which linguistic ....

....[5, pp. 157 161] This notion of a semantic network based discourse was from early on an objective within hypertext research [18, 27] Since then we have seen further developments on modelling argumentative discourse in general [16] sophisticated requirements for scholarly argumentation [31, 2813,14], or establishing large narratives [62] An important role in these approaches plays the role of linking, as the mechanism to represent the dynamic and rhetoric of hypertext, a theme common in hypertext literature [6, 34, 40, 33, 60 , 70 ] In fact, some work describes in some detail the ....

Kolb, D. (1997). Scholarly Hypertext: Self-Represented Complexity. Proceedings of the 8th ACM conference on Hypertext and Hypermedia, pp. 29 - 37, April 6-11, Southampton, UK.

....their technology ideology of hypertext to various paradigms of textual theory [1, p. 25] The justification of the ideological claims made on behalf of hypertext often takes one of two forms: either a belief that hypertext possesses a new critical and reflexive potential (Landow, Bolter, Kolb [17]) for some, hypertext is even explicitly connected to a particular philosophy or critical attitude [30] or, alternatively, an idea, already present in Bush s idea of the Memex , that hypertext is somehow closer to human associative thinking than printed text [6] 4] Apart from the ....

....the scholarly archive, and their hypertextualization. SCHOLARLY TEXTS AND ARCHIVES Here, I will focus on the scholarly text as a specific (super) genre, as opposed to literary texts, informative texts (such as manuals) and other (super)genres. On the whole, this distinction corresponds with Kolb [17], yet the texts produced in the sciences, the social sciences and the humanities are all included in the concept of scholarly text. In line with this distinction, scholarly archives refers to collections of scholarly texts and the catalogues and reference works giving access to them. Hypertext ....

[Article contains additional citation context not shown here]

Kolb, D. (1997) "Scholarly Hypertext: SelfRepresented Complexity", in Proceedings of the eighth ACM conference on Hypertext, pp. 29-37.

....a reluctance or inability on the part of untrained users to make the structure of too many ideas and concepts explicit. Even at this level, we envisage the need for shades of discourse level (implied by the need for composites) However, closely related work on hypertextual argumentation by Kolb [13] and Carter [8] describes the reification of argumentation structure at a finer granularity, suggesting possible uses of ScholOnto if there was the demand for its ontology to be refined to support fine grained argumentation. This corresponds to a requirement to represent intra document as well as ....

Kolb, D. Scholarly Hypertext: Self-Represented Complexity. In Proceedings of The Eighth ACM Conference on Hypertext, Southampton, 1997, pp. 29-37

....at a fine granularity, but initially, we suspect most will not have the literacy skills or time to do so. There are, however, intruiging possibilities for the future role of non linear argumentation using native hypertext structures, and we are following with interest the work of Kolb [34] [35], Carter [13] and others. We intend that our discourse ontology be extendible to include the kinds of new constructs and composite structures required as this strand of work develops. 2 It has been suggested to us that some communities may wish to moderate their ScholOnto networks to maintain ....

Kolb, D. Scholarly Hypertext: Self-Represented Complexity. In Proceedings of The Eighth ACM Conference on Hypertext, Southampton, 1997, pp. 29-37

Online articles have much greater impact   More about CiteSeer.IST   Add search form to your site   Submit documents   Feedback  

CiteSeer.IST - Copyright Penn State and NEC