See this document in CiteSeerX!

A Rigorous Investigation Of "Evidence" And "Occam Factors" In Bayesian Reasoning  (Make Corrections)  
David H. Wolpert



  Home/Search   Context   Related

 
View or download:
ohiostate.edu/pub...pert.evidence.ps.Z
Cached:  PS.gz  PS  PDF   Image  Update  Help

From:  egbert.cistron.nl/neuroprose (more)
(Enter author homepages)

Rate this article: (best)
  Comment on this article  
(Enter summary)

Abstract: : This paper first reviews the reasoning behind the Bayesian "evidence" procedure for setting parameters in the probability distributions involved in inductive inference. This paper then proves that the evidence procedure is incorrect. More precisely, this paper proves that the assumptions going into the evidence procedure do not, as claimed, "let the data determine the distributions ". Instead, those assumptions simply amount to an implicit replacement of the original distributions, containing ... (Update)

Active bibliography (related documents):   More   All
0.2:   A Market Framework for Pooling Opinions - Pennock, Wellman (1998)   (Correct)
0.2:   Using Model/Data Simulations to Detect Streakiness - Jim Albert   (Correct)
0.1:   The Relationship between PAC, the Statistical Physics framework.. - Wolpert (1994)   (Correct)

Similar documents based on text:   More   All
0.1:   Reading the Generalizer's Mind - Chris Thornton And   (Correct)
0.1:   On Overfitting Avoidance As Bias - Wolpert (1993)   (Correct)
0.1:   Reconciling Bayesian and Non-Bayesian Analysis - Wolpert (1994)   (Correct)

BibTeX entry:   (Update)

@techreport{ wolpert92rigorous,
    author = "D. H. Wolpert",
    title = "A rigorous investigation of `evidence' and `{O}ccam factors' in {B}ayesian reasoning'",
    number = "T.R. 92-03-013",
    year = "1992",
    url = "citeseer.ist.psu.edu/298958.html" }
Citations (may not include all citations):
537   A theory of the learnable (context) - Valiant - 1984
465   Learnability and Vapnik-Chervonenkis dimension (context) - Blumer - 1989
367   Stacked Generalization - Wolpert
244   Bayesian Interpolation - MacKay - 1991
96   Occam's razor (context) - Blumer - 1987
91   Bayesian back-propagation (context) - Buntine, Weigend - 1991
87   Axiomatic derivation of the principle of maximum entropy and.. (context) - Shore, Johnson - 1980
85   Bounds on the sample complexity of Bayesian learning using i.. - Haussler - 1991
58   Statistical mechanics of learning from examples (context) - Seung - 1991
50   Developments in maximum entropy data analysis (context) - Gull - 1989
45   the connection between in-sample testing and generalization .. (context) - Wolpert
33   Consistent inference of probabilities in layered networks: p.. (context) - Tishby - 1989
26   Exhaustive Learning (context) - Schwartz - 1990
21   Generalization performance of Bayes optimal classification a.. (context) - Opper, Haussler - 1991
19   Classic maximum entropy (context) - Skilling - 1989
17   Computers and the theory of statistics: thinking the unthink.. (context) - Efron - 1979
17   Fundamentals of MaxEnt in data analysis (context) - Skilling - 1991
4   Journal of the American Statistical Association (context) - Morris - 1983
1   Journal of the Royal Statistical Society B (context) - Lindley, Smith - 1972
1   statistical mechanics (context) - Wolpert
1   Maximum entropy and the nearly black object (context) - Gull, Commentary - 1992

Documents on the same site (http://www.egbert.cistron.nl/neuroprose.html):   More
A Widrow-Hoff learning-rule for a generalization of.. - Abdi, Valentin.. (1996)   (Correct)
A generalized autoassociator model for face processing.. - Abdi, Valentin, O'Toole (1996)   (Correct)
The Cocktail Party Listener - Abolfazlian, Karlsen   (Correct)

Online articles have much greater impact   More about CiteSeer.IST   Add search form to your site   Submit documents   Feedback  

CiteSeer.IST - Copyright Penn State and NEC