MetaCartSign in to MyCiteSeer

Include Citations | Advanced Search | Help

Include Citations | Advanced Search | Help

  A Correspondence between Nuprl, the Ramified Theory of Types and Pure Type Systems

Download:
Download as a PDF | Download as a PS
by Fairouz Kamareddine, Twan Laan
http://www.macs.hw.ac.uk/~fairouz/papers/research-reports/Glasgow-TR-97-09.ps
Add To MetaCart

Abstract:

In Russell's Ramified Theory of Types rtt, two hierarchical concepts dominate: orders and types. The use of orders has as a consequence that the logic part of rtt is predicative. The concept of order however, is almost dead since Ramsey eliminated it from rtt. This is why we find Church's simple theory of types (which uses the type concept without the order one) at the bottom of the Barendregt Cube rather than rtt. Despite the disappearence of orders which have a strong correlation with predicativity, predicative logic still plays an influential role in Computer Science. An important example is the proof checker Nuprl, which is based on Martin-Lof's Type Theory which uses type universes. Those type universes, and also degrees of expressions in Automath, are closely related to orders. In this paper, we show that orders have not disappeared from modern logic and computer science, rather, orders play a crucial role in understanding the hierarchy of modern systems. In order to achieve our goal, we concentrate on Nuprl. The novelty of our paper lies in: 1) the revival of Russell's orders, 2) the placing of the historical system rtt underlying the famous Principia Mathematica in a context with a modern system of computer mathematics (Nuprl) and modern type theories (Martin-Lof's type theory and PTSs), and 3) the presentation of a complex type system (Nuprl) as a simple and compact PTS. 1

Citations

604 A formulation of the simple theory of types – Church - 1940
579 Term rewriting systems – Klop - 1992
444 Lambda calculi with types – Barendregt - 1991
372 The Calculus of Constructions – Coquand, Huet - 1988
356 The formulas-as-types notion of construction – Howard - 1980
266 1984] Intuitionistic Type Theory – Martin-Löf
213 Constructive mathematics and computer programming – Martin-Löf - 1979
113 An intuitionistic theory of types: predicative part – Martin-Lof - 1975
80 Mathematical logic as based on the theory of types – Russell - 1908
78 Outline of a Theory of Truth – Kripke - 1975
69 Principia Mathematica – Whitehead, Russel - 1913
55 The Principles of Mathematics – Russell - 1903
51 Wahrheitsbegriff in den Formalisierten Sprachen”, Studia Philosophica – Tarski, “Der - 1935
31 The Foundations of Mathematics – Ramsey - 1925
22 Een nadere bewijstheoretische analyse van GSTT's – Terlouw - 1989
17 Grundgesetze der Arithmetik, begriffsschriftlich abgeleitet, 2 vols. Jena: Pohle. English translation – Frege - 1903
16 The Nuprl proof development system, Version 4.1 reference manual and user's guide – Jackson - 1994
11 Grundzüge der Theoretischen Logik. Die Grundlehren der – Hilbert, Ackermann - 1928
9 German; also in: Das Kontinuum und andere Monographien, Chelsea Pub.Comp – Veit, Leipzig - 1918
8 et al. The Coq proof assistant version 5.6, Users guide. Rapport de recherche 134 – Dowek - 1991
2 et al. Implementing Maths with the Nuprl Proof Development System – Constable - 1986
1 Enhancing the Nuprl Proff Development System and Applying it to Computational Abstract Algebra – Jackson - 1995
1 A reflection on Russell's ramified types and Kripke's hierarchy of truths – Kamareddine, Laan - 1996
1 A modern elaboration of the Ramified Theory of Types – Laan - 1996